Tank vs. Tankless Water Heaters
A tank keeps a supply of hot water ready; a tankless heats water only as it flows. Tankless can last longer and waste less energy, but it asks more of your gas line, venting and upkeep. Here's how they compare, with the sources behind each point.
By Frontline Plumbing · Updated
Efficiency and lifespan
The Department of Energy says gas tankless heaters can be 24% to 34% more energy efficient than conventional storage tanks in homes that use 41 gallons of hot water a day or less, and 8% to 14% more in homes that use a lot, around 86 gallons a day.
On lifespan, the DOE says most storage water heaters last 10 to 15 years and tankless heaters can last more than 20.
Electric tanks and electric tankless heaters aren't ENERGY STAR eligible; the DOE says that's because they're already highly efficient, with little room to improve. For electric homes, the DOE says heat pump water heaters can be two to three times more energy efficient than conventional electric water heaters.
Gas, venting and power
This is where most tank-to-tankless swaps get decided. A gas tankless burns a lot of gas while it runs: one Rheem condensing unit is rated at 199,000 Btu an hour. Navien's installation guide says the gas meter has to cover every connected appliance at once, recommends the water heater be the first appliance on the gas line, and warns against 1/2-inch corrugated connectors.
ENERGY STAR's checklist for a retrofit asks the installer to confirm the right flow size, whether the existing gas line is sufficient, whether there's electricity near the heater for forced-vent models, and how the exhaust will be vented. ENERGY STAR also notes the installer may need time to order the right model, and the install may take longer than a standard water heater.
In our own tankless swap-outs, that means new isolation valves and service ports, gas line sizing with a regulator when needed, code-compliant venting, and a condensate drain with a neutralizer when the unit requires one.
Flow: how much hot water at once
A tank is rated by how much it holds; a tankless by how many gallons a minute it can heat. ENERGY STAR's average figures: a shower or tub 2.5 gallons a minute, a clothes washer 3.3, a kitchen or bathroom sink 2.2 and a dishwasher 1.3. Add up what runs at the same time in your house. The DOE notes that if you use hot water in several places at the same time, you may need two or more tankless units.
A tankless also needs a minimum flow to fire, 0.5 gallons a minute on one Rheem model, and A.O. Smith describes the cold water sandwich: an unexpected burst of cold water. Models with a built-in buffer tank, like Navien's ComfortFlow units, are one answer.
A tank's limit is recovery. A.O. Smith says a gas tank needs 30 to 40 minutes to recover and an electric one 60 to 90, which is why back-to-back showers can run a tank cold.
Upkeep
A tankless needs descaling; A.O. Smith says once a year, especially with hard water. A tank needs its relief valve tested once a year, its anode rod checked, and sediment drained per its manual. Our guide to how long water heaters last covers the tank side in detail.
What we see
One of our recent tankless jobs started with a failed tank: when one family's 9-year-old water heater leaked while they were on vacation, they chose tankless after hearing the options. We install plenty of tanks too, most often Bradford White; both are good answers in the right house.
Common Questions
Want a plumber to look at yours?
Frontline Plumbing is a veteran-owned plumber in Greer, SC, working across the Upstate.
More Guides
- How Long Do Water Heaters Last?How long tanks and tankless heaters last, what shortens their life, and how to read the age off the label.
- Frozen and Burst Pipes in the UpstateHow cold it has to get, which pipes freeze first, how much to drip, how to thaw, and what to do if one bursts.
- PEX vs. Copper for Repiping a HouseWhat South Carolina's code allows, how PEX handles chlorinated water and sunlight, freezing, and why we repipe in PEX.
- How to Shut Off the Water to Your HouseWhere the main shutoff usually is, how to turn it, the meter, the water heater, and what to do if the valve won't move.
- Winterizing Your Plumbing in the UpstateHow often it freezes here, what actually freezes, a before-the-freeze checklist, sprinklers, vacant homes and wells.